I really believe craft brewers have collectively lost
their minds. It was 93° here today, and
what do I see on the shelf staring back at me like a demon
preparing to suck the life out of me? Pumpkin beer--
the scourge of the craft beer movement. And I use the
term " craft" loosely in this instance.
I talked to a couple of brewers recently, and they hate making the stuff. They only do it because it sells. Why it sells, I have no idea. I guess there really is no accounting for taste. Very few styles of beer can handle being over the top with flavor, with IPA's and Imperial Stouts coming to mind here. But they at least still taste like beer. However, some barrel aged stouts (and others) are getting almost as bad as pumpkin beer in the over the top, completely overdone, in your face flavor, that tastes nothing like beer but that's a topic for another post.
Craft brewing is all about freshness and quality. Pumpkin beer made in June or July is lacking one key ingredient that's fresh, the pumpkin. The "star" of this show. Then again, maybe the pumpkin is just a bit player. More on that coming up.
All over this country brewers were breaking their wrists opening canned pumpkin paste to dump in their fermenters. I'll say that again so it sinks in, canned pumpkin paste. Doesn't sound very crafty to me. I wouldn't even be surprised if the paste was bought at Sam's Club. That's if they bother to use real pumpkin at all. Here the pumpkin isn't even a bit player. Some, it seems, just dump a bunch of spice in the beer and call it a day. So much spice in fact, that I hesitate to even call it beer. It fails to resemble beer in any way save for one-- the fact that it's carbonated liquid. There isn't even a hint of what actual beer tastes like in "pumpkin beer."
I've had samples where I felt like taking a knife to my tongue to scrape off the gritty residue of clove and cinnamon. I'm not sure why the stuff isn't just called what it really is, Carbonated, Liquid Spice.
You'd swear everyone lost the ability to chew and brewers decided to make it easier for people by putting pie in a giant industrial blender and bottling it up so everyone can enjoy a nice drink of pie.
Now, don't get me wrong, I like pumpkin pie. I just like it in November when there are snow flurries in the air, football is on TV and I've just stuffed myself into a tryptophan coma on Thanksgiving. That's a great time to eat pumpkin pie, there's never a good time to drink it. Especially when it's 95° outside with enough humidity to make a snake sweat.
Pumpkin beer is dumb. Pumpkin beer in August is on the same level of stupidity as Christmas displays at Wal-Mart in September. Come on craft brewers, don't stoop to the level of retailers taking the fun out of Christmas by shoving it in your face for months on end.
Then throw in the people singing the praises of Pumpking or The Great Pumpkin or Whole Hog, Pumpkin Pumpkin Pumpkin OMG!!!!!1!!1 FTW!!!!
Gaaaaahh! Stop the bus, I want to get off.